Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of Catch-1782 by RandomJoke

25 May 2025

This review contains spoilers!

I enjoyed this one, but I can totally see why people wouldn't. Mind you, I just listened to it recently and really went into blind.

If there is anything I can praise, it's atmosphere, it does do a lot of the heavy lifting with this one, because frankly the Plot is a bit odd. There are Aspects to it, the Way Time Travel is used here is done quite well. I do like how Mel-centric this one, I think Bonnie does give a good Performance. I enjoyed Uncle John. And I would be lying if I didn't say it *tried* to do a lot of interesting Things, some of which I wish were fleshed out more, some others I am still unsure what to make out of it. Fleshing out is a good Word, probably, especially for the ending. I do feel like this Story desperately needs an Epilogue with Mel, considering she really went through a rough Time with this one, it doesn't feel quite right how we never really deal with it at the End.

Yet another bizarre Beast to tackle in the Monthlies.

 


RandomJoke

View profile