Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time! 

“Caged: Experimentation, Empathy, and Alien Perspectives”

Caged opens with an intriguing setup, evoking shades of Carnival of Monsters, The War Games, and even Winner Takes All. The story places the Doctor and Ruby at the heart of a mysterious experiment involving two alien species: one conducting the research and the other unwittingly subjected to it.

This layered premise immediately sparks curiosity, blending the classic mystery-adventure vibes of Doctor Who with a modern focus on moral complexity.

Lore Over Momentum

The first third of the story takes its time, focusing on world-building and the gradual unfolding of the experiment rather than driving the plot forward. Una McCormack’s intricate plotting ensures that every revelation feels earned, but the slow pace may test the patience of some listeners.

The alien planet and its inhabitants are richly detailed, and the interplay between the octopus-like researchers and their "guinea pigs" adds a fascinating depth to the narrative.

Character Spotlights

The Doctor is wonderfully written here, fully embodying his inquisitive, empathetic, and proactive nature. He takes an active role in uncovering the truth and navigating the moral dilemmas presented by the experiment.

Ruby is equally well-realised, her characterisation aligning closely with her TV counterpart. Her empathy and sharp instincts shine, providing an effective foil to the Doctor’s more methodical approach.

Chirracharr, one of the guinea pig-like aliens, is a delightful addition. Their childlike curiosity and innocence make them a standout character, acting as a proto-companion and asking the questions that cut to the heart of the story’s themes. Their resemblance to a cuddly Pokémon only adds to their charm.

Themes of Coexistence and Understanding

The story’s octopus-like aliens are deeply devoted to their experiments, motivated by a fear of loneliness in the universe. This adds a poignant layer to their morally ambiguous actions, as their desire to create a world for others to inhabit clashes with their treatment of sentient beings as test subjects.

Themes of xenophobia, humanity, and mutual understanding are woven throughout the narrative. The exploration of how different intelligent life forms can learn to coexist, despite their differences and past wrongs, is both timely and timeless.

Family and Forgiveness

Season 1's recurring themes of family and connection are echoed here. The idea of extending empathy, even to those who have wronged you, resonates strongly. The resolution, which hinges on the aliens’ willingness to overcome their prejudices and work together, is a heartwarming conclusion to a story steeped in tension and moral quandaries.

The Verdict: A Thoughtful Slow Burn

Caged is a richly detailed and morally complex tale that showcases the best of Doctor Who’s ability to tackle weighty themes within a fantastical framework. While the pacing in the first third may feel sluggish, the payoff is a poignant and rewarding exploration of coexistence and empathy.

📝Verdict: 76/100