Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of Birthright by RandomJoke

15 June 2025

I think, I mentioned it not long ago but reading this one was a tough one. And so far from the few VNAs that I read it was certainly the second weakest (but granted I haven’t read all that much from them).
While Birthright has some great Ideas to it, I mean the Plot is quite genius to really show us this TARDIS Team, even if this Story is very much more cut out as a Doctor-Lite story than anything else. I do think there are some nice Moments to be found, while I am not the biggest Fan of the actual Prose, they do move together quite nicely for the most Part. Although I am also not quite sold on how the Author writes certain Characters at times. That said, there is just something about this one, that just didn’t quite click with me.

I do overall prefer the Benny Adaption over the original Novel, even if that one is also more on the weaker Side of her first Series.


RandomJoke

View profile