I didn't hate this one as much as others seem to, it was just alright. I liked the idea of someone looking through the window into the Doctor's adventures, but I do agree it could have been conveyed a lot better. I'm not exactly a champion of A Stain of Red in the Sand, but it's not the worst Short Trip I've encountered by a wide margin and David Troughton is always a fun performer to listen to, especially when he is doing so on behalf of his father.