Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of A Dog’s Life by MrColdStream

11 February 2025

This review contains spoilers!

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

“A DOG’S LIFE: K9’S PERSPECTIVE OVERLOAD”

A Dog’s Life attempts a unique approach by telling the story from K9 Mark III’s perspective, detailing his time with Sarah Jane Smith. While this could have been a fun and insightful look into the robotic dog’s mind, the execution makes for a frustrating read. K9’s narration is overloaded with technological jargon, and while it’s true to his character, it quickly becomes tiresome and difficult to follow.

STYLE OVER SUBSTANCE

The story itself is a solid concept—K9, in his old and failing state, desperately tries to get Sarah Jane to fix him while simultaneously defending her home from burglars. The problem is that the excessive use of K9’s robotic analysis and rigid dialogue structure overshadows the emotional core. Instead of an engaging “a dog is man’s best friend” tale, the stylised writing makes it hard to connect with what should be a touching or exciting narrative.

VERDICT: A CLEVER IDEA WITH CLUNKY EXECUTION

The premise of A Dog’s Life had potential, but the overbearing narrative style makes it more of a chore than a joy to read. While K9’s unique perspective could have offered charm and insight, it instead becomes an obstacle, making this story difficult to engage with.

📝2/10


MrColdStream

View profile